Skip to content

GRA · Payments and Market Infrastructure

Spatial financeWhere capital meets hazard, exposure and transition

Retail and wholesale payments

Payment systems carry everything from card purchases to interbank settlements worth large sums each day. Retail systems handle many small payments; wholesale systems settle large-value payments, usually in central bank money. Each concentrates operational and liquidity risk at a few nodes. This page sets out how payment system risk develops and spreads, how it is measured, and the overseers, operators and participants who decide.

01تابلۆ

چۆن کارەکە بەڕێوە دەچێت.

سیستەمەکان · دەوروبەری ئەم بابەتەنموونەیی

RTGS operations console

Retail and wholesale payments · RTGS system · Business day 126

  • Value settled today
    61ملیاری ناوخۆییچالاک
  • Payments queued
    2720چاودێری
  • بەردەستبوون، % ئەم مانگە
    100.0ئاسایی
  • Participants below liquidity floor
    2ئاگادارکردنەوە
Queue building at peakGRA · Payments and Market Infrastructure

Intraday liquidity, system

Incident and failover log

  1. 09:42INCParticipant P-12 message delay
  2. 10:30LSMLiquidity saving cycle released 37 payments
  3. 14:00CUTCustomer payment cut-off
  4. Q3TESTContingency site failover in 63 min
RTGS operations console: the screen’s structure, terms and states for Retail and wholesale payments.Example names and illustrative values; a design, not a record or a live system.

Fig.RTGS operations console: example names and illustrative values, not a record or a live system.

02پرسیارەکە

Retail and wholesale payments: how the risk develops.

Payment rails and economic continuity. The dossier below sets out how the risk develops, what is measured, where the data come from, how it is modelled and who decides.

میکانیزم

Liquidity must flow intraday

Participants need liquidity to send payments before receiving others. If one large participant holds back, others are short and the system can gridlock.

میکانیزم

Concentration at the core

A few systems and settlement banks process most value. An outage at one stops payments for every participant and their customers.

میکانیزم

Instant payments run continuously

Round-the-clock instant payments leave no batch window for recovery and move funds before fraud checks finish, changing the risk profile.

میکانیزم

Settlement asset matters

Settlement in central bank money carries no credit risk; settlement in commercial bank money exposes participants to the settlement bank.

03تاقیکردنەوەی فشار

How a shock to assets becomes a system loss.

ئەو سەرمایەیەی سیستەمەکە دوای سەرایەتی نێوان بانکەکان لەدەستی دەدات، بەراورد بە زەبرە سەرەتاییەکە، کاتێک ڕێژەی قەرزکاری، پەیوەندیی نێوانیان و ڕێژەی گەڕانەوە دەگۆڕێن، کە کرۆکی تاقیکردنەوەی فشاری ئیحتیاتیی ماکرۆیە. مۆدێلێکی فێرکارییە بە بەهای نموونەیی دیاریکراو، نەک پێشبینی.

کۆنترۆڵەکان

Fall in external assets
2.0%
Leverage (assets over equity)
10 جار
Interbank share of assets
10%
Recovery on interbank claims
40%
Banks in the system
20
بانکە سەرەکییەکان
20% of banks

خوێندنەوەکان

Equity lost to the initial shock
18.0%
Equity lost after contagion
45.0%
Added by contagion (DebtRank)
27.0 خاڵ
Banks in default
0
ژمارە، ڕێگا و سەرچاوەکان
خولSystem equity lost (%)Banks in default
018.000
128.800
235.280
339.170
441.500
542.900
643.740
744.240
844.550
944.730
1044.840
1144.900
1244.940
1344.960
1444.980
1544.990
1644.990
1745.000
1845.000
1945.000
2045.000
2145.000
2245.000
2345.000
2445.000
2545.000
2645.000
2745.000
2845.000
2945.000
3045.000

ڕێگاکان

  1. DebtRank Battiston and others (2012), Scientific Reports 2:541
  2. Differential DebtRank Bardoscia and others (2015), PLOS ONE 10
  3. Contagion in financial networks Gai and Kapadia (2010), Proc. R. Soc. A 466
  4. Clearing in financial networks Eisenberg and Noe (2001), Management Science 47
  5. پەنجەی نادڵنیایی (مۆنتی کارلۆی پارامیتەر) Spiegelhalter, Pearson و Short (2011)، Visualising uncertainty about the future، Science 333
  6. هەستیاریی یەک-یەک (تۆرناد) Saltelli و ئەوانی دیکە (2008)، Global Sensitivity Analysis: The Primer، Wiley

داتا

No observed data enters this model: it runs on the teaching values set by the controls, to be replaced with a programme’s own evidence.

How a shock to assets becomes a system loss. Illustrative teaching model: it runs on the values set by the controls, not on measured data. Methods: DebtRank (Battiston and others (2012), Scientific Reports 2:541); Differential DebtRank (Bardoscia and others (2015), PLOS ONE 10); Contagion in financial networks (Gai and Kapadia (2010), Proc. R. Soc. A 466).

لە ناو شەش کۆڵەکەکەدا، بە سەرپەرشتیی Nexus Consortium

04نیشاندەرەکان

What is measured, and how well.

Each indicator carries its unit, its cadence, the kind of source behind it and the evidence label a value would carry. No values are shown: a programme supplies them under its own authority.

نیشاندەریەکەڕیتمSource typeناونیشان
Value and volume of payments by systemcurrency and count per yearساڵانەCPMI Red Book statisticsئامارە بڵاوکراوەکان
System availabilitypercent of scheduled operating timeمانگانەOperator disclosuresDECLARED
Intraday liquidity usagepeak use as share of available liquiditydailyParticipant and operator dataڕاپۆرتکراو
Payment system outagescount and duration in minutesper incidentOperator and overseer reportsئامارە بڵاوکراوەکان
Instant payment share of credit transferspercentساڵانەCentral bank statisticsئامارە بڵاوکراوەکان
Settlement in central bank moneyshare of valueساڵانەCentral bank statisticsئامارە بڵاوکراوەکان
05Exposure, loss and capital

What retail and wholesale payments means for exposure, loss and capital.

The exposure, loss, scenario and capital views a risk officer, supervisor or ministry of finance would ask for, with the frameworks they report against. Structures follow supervisory and actuarial practice. Values are illustrative: never prices, ratings or advice.

Transmission channels

How a shock in retail and wholesale payments reaches credit, market, underwriting, liquidity and operational risk, and feeds back.

Channel structure after the Basel Committee’s work on climate-related risk drivers and transmission channels; links shown are typical paths, not estimated exposures.
NGFS climate scenarios · Network for Greening the Financial SystemIFRS S2 Climate-related Disclosures · ISSBTCFD recommendations · Financial Stability Board TCFDPrinciples for the effective management of climate-related financial risks · Basel Committee on Banking Supervision
06سەرچاوەکان

Where the evidence comes from.

Named public datasets and institutional records, each with its licence class. Sources by agreement are used only under their terms and never republished.

سەرچاوەWhat it givesLicence class
CPMI Red Book statisticsPayment, clearing and settlement statistics by countryFree, BIS terms
ECB payment statisticsEuro area payment volumes and valuesFree, ECB reuse terms
Federal Reserve Financial Services and Fedwire statisticsUnited States wholesale payment volumesدۆمەینی گشتی
PFMI disclosure frameworks published by operatorsSelf-assessments against the PFMIPublic records, terms per operator
Bank of England RTGS and CHAPS reportsOperation and resilience of UK high-value paymentsFree, Bank of England terms
07بڕیارەکان

Who decides, and what the evidence serves.

Payments and Market Infrastructure prepares evidence. The decisions below are taken by the authorities named, under their own rules, and never by the platform.

کێ بڕیار دەداتپرسیارەکەEvidence this page serves
Central bank overseersWhether systems meet the PFMI and what remediation is neededSelf-assessments, incidents and availability data
System operators’ boardsHow to invest in resilience and liquidity-saving mechanismsIncident history and participant behaviour data
Participant banksHow much intraday liquidity to hold and how to manage payment timingLiquidity usage and stress evidence
Legislators and regulatorsWhether to mandate instant payment access or safeguardsMarket and fraud evidence

Outputs this topic produces

  • Guide to retail, wholesale and instant payment systems and their risks
  • Brief on intraday liquidity and gridlock
  • Method note on payment system availability measures
  • Questions for participants on settlement bank dependence
08Core questions

What the industry asks.

Every economic transaction ends in a payment. When retail rails fail, shops cannot sell and people cannot pay; when wholesale rails fail, banks cannot settle and markets seize. The move to instant, round-the-clock payments improves service but leaves less time to recover from problems. Understanding how rails are built and connected is the starting point for keeping the economy running through disruption.

  • Which payment rails carry which kinds of payments, and how do they connect to each other and to settlement in central bank money?
  • What are the critical functions of each rail, and what is the tolerable period of disruption for each?
  • How do participants manage liquidity in real-time systems, and what happens when expected payments do not arrive?
  • What contingency arrangements exist if a rail is unavailable?
09Mechanisms

How the infrastructure works and fails.

Payment rails differ in speed, value, settlement model and operator.

فرۆشتنی تاک

High volume, low value

Card schemes, automated clearing houses and instant payment systems, often settling net positions later in central bank money.

Wholesale

Low volume, high value

Real-time gross settlement systems settle each payment individually and with finality, usually operated by central banks.

شلەمەنی

Funding the flows

Participants need liquidity to make payments before receiving others. Queuing, liquidity-saving mechanisms and central bank credit help.

Retail and wholesale rails are linked. Retail systems typically settle their net positions in the wholesale system, and banks depend on wholesale settlement to fund retail payments. A problem in either can therefore spread to the other. Mapping these links, and the timing of settlement cycles between them, is central to understanding how a disruption would unfold.

10ڕێگا و بەڵگە

How the evidence is built, and its limits.

  1. 01

    System statistics

    Published volumes, values and availability statistics. Detailed operational data are rarely public.

  2. 02

    Incident reports

    Published reports of outages and their causes. Detail varies by jurisdiction and operator.

  3. 03

    Liquidity simulation

    Simulation of payment flows under stress, applying network science and contagion. Requires transaction data usually available only to operators and overseers.

  4. 04

    Architecture analysis

    Analysis of system design and dependencies, applying payment and financial market technology.

11ڕێگاکان

How it is studied, and what the methods cannot say.

  1. Payment and financial market technologyLiquidity-saving mechanisms · ISO 20022 data quality · Settlement cycle designApplied here
  2. Network science and contagionPayment flow networks · Shared provider mapping · CCP membership networksApplied here
  3. Reliability and resilience engineeringImpact tolerance setting · Recovery design · Learning from incidentsApplied here
12پرسیارەکان

پرسیار و وەڵام.

What is a real-time gross settlement system?
A system in which large-value payments settle individually and immediately in central bank money, removing settlement credit risk between banks.
Why can payment systems gridlock?
Because each participant waits for incoming payments before sending its own. If enough participants wait, payments stop flowing. Liquidity-saving mechanisms reduce this.
What changes with instant payments?
Payments settle in seconds at any time, which benefits users but removes time for fraud checks and requires continuous operation and liquidity.
What is real-time gross settlement?
A system in which each payment is settled individually and immediately in central bank money, with finality, rather than being netted with others.
Why are instant payments a resilience challenge?
Because they operate continuously, leaving no overnight window for maintenance or recovery, and because errors and fraud move as fast as legitimate payments.
Does GRA operate or oversee payment systems?
No. Operation and oversight belong to operators and central banks.
What is a tolerable period of disruption?
The longest time a critical function can be unavailable before causing serious harm. Infrastructures and authorities define it for each function.
ڕاپۆرتەکانبەشداربە

لەم لاپەڕەیەوە بەڵگە پێشکەش بکە.

Reports بڵاوکراوەی وەرزیی کۆنسۆرتیۆم ـە. ئەوەی تۆ لەسەر ئەم بابەتە دەیزانیت دەتوانێت لە وەشانی داهاتوودا ببێتە بەڵگە، کەیس یان ڕاستکردنەوە، بە ناوی خۆتەوە و لەژێر CC BY 4.0 بڵاو دەکرێتەوە کاتێک کاری خۆتە.

Global Risks AlliancePayments and Market InfrastructureStrategic SystemsScenario and Stress-Test

هەرگیز داتای کەسی، وردەکاریی هەستیاری ژێرخان یان هیچ شتێک مەنێرە کە مافی بڵاوکردنەوەت نییە. بەشدارییەک پێش بەکارهێنان پێداچوونەوەی بۆ دەکرێت؛ ناردنی ماف نابەخشێت بە نووسەرایەتی یان بەڕێوەبردنی ڕاگەیاندن، و پاڵپشتی دارایی هەرگیز دۆزینەوەیەک ناکڕێت.

پارەدان و ژێرخانی بازاڕ

Bring an exposure or capital question to the Alliance.

زانیاری و پرسیار ئەمڕۆ کراوەن. پرسیارێک ژمارەی ئاماژەی پێدەدرێت و هەنگاوی دواتر دیاری دەکات؛ داواکاری، پارەدان، تەرخانکردنی کۆمپیوتەر و تۆمارکردن تەنیا کاتێک دەکرێنەوە کە تیم، مەرج و توانای پێداچوونەوەیان هەبێت.