Skip to content

GRA · Public Finance and Sovereign Debt

Spatial financeWhere capital meets hazard, exposure and transition

Subnational fiscal risk

Regions, provinces and cities deliver much public spending and in many countries borrow. Their fiscal position depends on transfers from the centre, own revenue and rules on borrowing. Expectations of central bailouts can encourage overborrowing. This page sets out how subnational fiscal risk develops and reaches the national budget, how it is measured, and who decides.

01Qeyd

Subnational fiscal risk on the record.

02Pirs

Subnational fiscal risk: how the risk develops.

Local and provincial budget shocks. The dossier below sets out how the risk develops, what is measured, where the data come from, how it is modelled and who decides.

Mekanîzma

Vertical imbalance

Subnational governments often spend more than they raise, relying on transfers. Cuts or delays in transfers squeeze services and push them to borrow.

Mekanîzma

Bailout expectations soften discipline

If lenders and local leaders expect the centre to rescue a struggling region, they lend and borrow more freely, and the centre’s debt absorbs the cost.

Mekanîzma

Off-budget vehicles hide debt

Local government financing vehicles and municipal enterprises borrow outside fiscal rules, accumulating debt that may not appear in published figures.

Mekanîzma

Rules differ in force

Borrowing limits, balanced budget rules and market discipline restrain subnational debt to different degrees. Enforcement and data decide their effect.

03Spatial finance

A loan book under scenario families.

How physical and transition risk could reach a loan book under different scenarios. Illustrative design values.

A loan book across Europe under physical and transition risk.Design values; NGFS scenario names are labels only, not stress test results.
04Nîşander

What is measured, and how well.

Each indicator carries its unit, its cadence, the kind of source behind it and the evidence label a value would carry. No values are shown: a programme supplies them under its own authority.

NîşaneYekîneRîtmSource typeNîşan
Subnational government debtpercent of GDPsalaneGovernment finance statisticsStatîstîkên weşandî
Transfers as share of subnational revenuepercentsalaneGovernment finance statisticsStatîstîkên weşandî
Subnational borrowing rulescategoricalon changeLegislation and OECD databasesStatîstîkên weşandî
Arrears of subnational governmentscurrencyperiodicAudit and treasury reportsHATIYE RAPORKIRIN
Debt of local financing vehiclescurrencyperiodicStudies and published estimatesTEXMÎNKIRÎ
Subnational credit ratingsrating scaleperiodicRating agency publicationsHATIYE RAPORKIRIN
05Çavdêrî bike

Debt sustainability console.

Ekrana ku tîmek dê ji bo şopandina vê mijarê bikar bîne: pîvan, rewş û biryarên wê. Nav mînak in û nirx nîşander in.

Debt sustainability console: the screen’s structure, terms and states for Subnational fiscal risk.Example names and illustrative values; a design, not a record or a live system.
06Çavkanî

Where the evidence comes from.

Named public datasets and institutional records, each with its licence class. Sources by agreement are used only under their terms and never republished.

ÇavkanîWhat it givesLicence class
OECD Fiscal Decentralisation DatabaseSubnational revenue, spending and debtFree, OECD terms
IMF Government Finance StatisticsSubnational fiscal data by countryFree, IMF terms
World Observatory on Subnational Government Finance and InvestmentSubnational finance profilesFree to read, terms to check
IMF Article IV reports on countries with large local government debtAnalysis of subnational debt and vehiclesFree, IMF terms
National audit office reports on local government financesAudit findings on subnational financePublic records, terms per office
07Scenario model

Sovereign debt paths and the odds of breaching a threshold.

The distribution of debt paths, and the share above a threshold of concern at the horizon, that sovereign investors and rating analysts read from a fan chart. Teaching model with stated illustrative values, not a prediction. The map on this page shows Africa; the model itself is not tied to a place.

  • Median, 25% to 75% and 10% to 90% bands
  • Tu şok tune

Kontrol

Debt today
70% of GDP
Effective nominal interest rate
5.0%
Nominal GDP growth
4.5%
Primary balance
−0.5% of GDP
Volatility of growth
2.0 xal
Volatility of the interest rate
1.0 xal
Salên pêş
10 sal
Threshold of concern
90% of GDP

Xwendin

Median debt at the horizon
78% of GDP
Paths above the threshold at the horizon
2%
Primary balance that stabilises debt
0.3% of GDP
Jimar, rêbaz û çavkanî
Sal10%25%Medyan75%90%
070.070.070.070.070.0
168.769.770.871.972.8
268.869.971.673.574.8
369.070.772.374.476.4
469.170.973.175.377.6
569.471.674.176.278.6
669.872.374.777.580.1
770.373.175.778.481.4
870.973.876.479.883.1
971.574.177.380.584.3
1071.975.078.281.885.3

Rêbaz

  1. Debt dynamics and the interest-growth differential Blanchard (2019), Public debt and low interest rates, American Economic Review 109
  2. Stochastic fan charts Celasun, Debrun and Ostry (2006), IMF Staff Papers 53
  3. Sovereign risk and debt sustainability framework IMF (2022), Staff Guidance Note on the SRDSF

Dane

No observed data enters this model: it runs on the teaching values set by the controls, to be replaced with a programme’s own evidence.

Sovereign debt paths and the odds of breaching a threshold. Illustrative teaching model: it runs on the values set by the controls, not on measured data. Methods: Debt dynamics and the interest-growth differential (Blanchard (2019), Public debt and low interest rates, American Economic Review 109); Stochastic fan charts (Celasun, Debrun and Ostry (2006), IMF Staff Papers 53); Sovereign risk and debt sustainability framework (IMF (2022), Staff Guidance Note on the SRDSF).
08Biryar

Who decides, and what the evidence serves.

Public Finance and Sovereign Debt prepares evidence. The decisions below are taken by the authorities named, under their own rules, and never by the platform.

Kî biryarê didePirsEvidence this page serves
Central finance ministriesHow to design transfers and borrowing controlsSubnational data and comparative frameworks
Subnational governmentsHow much to borrow and through which entitiesOwn fiscal data and rules
Lenders and investorsWhether to lend and how to price support expectationsDisclosures and legal frameworks
LegislaturesWhat fiscal rules apply to lower levels of governmentComparative rules and outcomes

Outputs this topic produces

  • Guide to subnational fiscal frameworks
  • Comparative notes on borrowing rules
  • Brief on off-budget local financing vehicles
  • Questions for central governments on bailout risk
09Simulatorê cêwî û kaskade

Trace a shock in subnational fiscal risk to the balance sheet.

Assembled from the Nexus Standards area profile Disaster and climate risk finance: the shocks it names, the systems and sectors that carry the loss, the controls that dampen it and the data that observe it. Pick an initiating shock and step through the cascade to see which exposures it reaches and where losses could concentrate. The Map view places the run on an example geography with open data. Every weight is a stated assumption. An exercise, not a forecast, a valuation, a rating or investment advice. To model a place of your own choosing, open the full System Builder.

Metirsî

  • Tropical cyclone
  • Erdhej
  • Ice-jam flood
  • Storm surge (set off downstream)
  • Intense rainfall (set off downstream)
  • River flood (set off downstream)
  • Flash flood (set off downstream)
  • Dangerous surf (set off downstream)
  • Qutbûna berfireh a elektrîkê (li aliyê jêr çê dibe)
  • Koçberiya girseyî (li aliyê jêr çê dibe)
  • Coastal flood (set off downstream)
  • Aftershock sequence (set off downstream)
  • Fault surface rupture (set off downstream)
  • Soil liquefaction (set off downstream)
  • Slope slide (set off downstream)
  • Rockfall (set off downstream)
  • Tsunami (set off downstream)
  • Building collapse (set off downstream)

Kontrol

  • NS-0 Destûr û prensîb
  • NS-3 UNIyên tomara xetereyê (rêzimanî, nexşeya veguhastina ji pergala kevin, desthilata veqetandinê)
  • NS-9 UNI yên çarçoveyî (belavkirin, mînak, mînakên bernameyê)
  • NS-10 Polîtîka û xal (erkên ku makîne dikare bixwîne: pênase, girêdanî, nirxandin û sepandin)
  • NS-11 Piştrastkirin û çavdêrî (delîl, erêkirin, çavdêriya lihevhatina zero-trust)
  • NS-14 Lihevhatin û nexşeya li standardên derveyî
  • NRS-F8 Veguhastina xeterê ya parametrîk û li ser bingeha îndeksê
  • NRS-F7 Darayiya xetera karesatan û darayiya pêşwext amadekirî
  • NRS-H113 Malbata metirsiyê: Nazikiya pergala darayî (NHS-1 soc.financial-system)
  • NRS-H114 Malbata metirsiyê: Şokên makroaborî û darayiya giştî (NHS-1 soc.macro-fiscal)
  • NRS-D1 Pêşketina li gorî xeterê û sehkirina projeyan
  • NRS-H28 Malbata metirsiyê: Guherînên rewşa avhewayê (NHS-1 eco.climate-state)

Çavdêrî

  • ERA5 reanalysis (Copernicus Climate Data Store) (listed for reference)
  • CHIRPS quasi-global gridded precipitation (listed for reference)
  • USGS earthquake GeoJSON summary feeds (listed for reference)
  • Total public international support for national disaster risk reduction actions (Sendai indicator F-1)
  • Direct economic loss attributed to disasters in relation to global GDP

Erdnîgariya mînakê

  • Ewropaya Rojava: 152 şaneyên şeşgoşe
  • Rêjeya barînê, nîv saeta dawî (IMERG), NASA GIBS
  • Ronahiyên şevê îşev, qutbûn (VIIRS Day/Night Band), NASA GIBS
  • Ava rûyê erdê di nav ewr re, 30 m (radara OPERA DSWx-S1), NASA GIBS
  • Şiliya axa rûyê erdê (SMAP), NASA GIBS
10Core questions

What specialists ask.

  • How do subnational governments finance themselves, and how much can they borrow?
  • How exposed are local budgets to disasters, economic shocks and falling transfers?
  • When are central governments expected to support distressed subnational governments?
  • How do fiscal rules for subnational governments work in practice?
  • How do local governments finance climate adaptation and infrastructure?
11Exposure, loss and capital

What subnational fiscal risk means for exposure, loss and capital.

The exposure, loss, scenario and capital views a risk officer, supervisor or ministry of finance would ask for, with the frameworks they report against. Structures follow supervisory and actuarial practice. Values are illustrative: never prices, ratings or advice.

Capital, solvency and fiscal indicators

The indicators a risk officer, supervisor or ministry of finance reads first on subnational fiscal risk.

NîşaneYekîneWho reads itÇarçove
Public debt% ji GDPMinistries of finance, IMFDebt Sustainability Framework
Gross financing needs% of GDP per yearMinistries of finance, investorsDebt Sustainability Framework
Contingent liabilities% of GDP, by sourceMinistries of financeFiscal risk statements
Interest to revenue% of revenueMinistries of finance, rating usersPublic finance statistics
Sovereign spreadbasis points over a benchmarkInvestors, debt managersMarket data
CET1 ratio% of risk-weighted assetsBanks, supervisorsBasel framework
Rêjeya veşartina lîkîdîteyê% of stressed outflowsBanks, central banksBasel framework
Source: the frameworks named in each row. Indicator names, units and frameworks only; values belong to each institution’s own reporting and are never shown here.
NGFS climate scenarios · Network for Greening the Financial SystemIFRS S2 Climate-related Disclosures · ISSBTCFD recommendations · Financial Stability Board TCFDPrinciples for the effective management of climate-related financial risks · Basel Committee on Banking Supervision
12Mechanisms

Drivers and dynamics.

Subnational governments rely on their own taxes, transfers from central government and borrowing. Their revenue bases are often narrow and tied to local economic conditions, property values or specific industries. Disasters hit local budgets directly through damage to public assets and lost revenue. When central governments face fiscal stress, transfers to local governments are often cut, transmitting stress downwards.

The expectation of central government support creates moral hazard: if lenders and local governments expect a rescue, they may borrow too much. Many countries regulate subnational borrowing through fiscal rules, approval requirements or market discipline. Subnational debt, including that of local government financing vehicles in some systems, can be a significant and sometimes hidden source of national fiscal risk.

13Methods and limits

How it is studied.

  1. 01

    Fiscal capacity analysis

    Assessing revenue bases, spending needs and borrowing capacity, using economics and development economics.

  2. 02

    Shock analysis

    Testing local budgets against disaster and economic scenarios, using scenario design and stress testing.

  3. 03

    Institutional comparison

    Comparing intergovernmental fiscal arrangements and borrowing rules.

  4. 04

    Sînor

    Subnational data is often incomplete or inconsistent, arrangements vary greatly, and implicit central support is hard to measure.

14Rêbaz

How it is studied, and what the methods cannot say.

  1. Economics and development economicsDebt dynamics · Fiscal multipliers · Fiscal federalismApplied here
  2. EconometricsFiscal reaction functions · Revenue volatility · Disaster effects on public financeApplied here
  3. Decision analysis under uncertaintyDebt management strategy · Fiscal rule design · Guarantee approvalApplied here
15Pirs

Pirs û bersiv.

What is vertical fiscal imbalance?
The gap between subnational governments’ spending responsibilities and the revenue they raise themselves, usually filled by central transfers.
Why do bailout expectations matter?
Because if lenders expect the central government to cover subnational debts, they lend more cheaply and monitor less, encouraging overborrowing.
What is a local government financing vehicle?
A company set up by a local government to borrow and invest, often in infrastructure, outside the local budget.
Can a city or province default?
Yes, in many systems. Whether the central government intervenes depends on law, politics and the scale of the problem.
Why are subnational budgets vulnerable to disasters?
Because damage, relief costs and lost revenue fall locally, often on narrow revenue bases.
Does GRA assess subnational borrowers?
No. It studies the field at sector level.
Does GRA give advice on this topic?
No. GRA does not lend, underwrite, rate, invest, advise on or arrange transactions, including sovereign borrowing or debt restructuring, and it introduces no counterparties. Readiness work is not approval. Its analysis is shared, sector-level understanding.
rêzeya Pergalên StratejîkTevkarî bike

Ji vê rûpelê delîl bidin.

Reports weşana sê mehane ya Konsorsiyûmê ye. Tiştê ku tu li ser vê mijarê dizanî dikare di çapa pêş de bibe delîl, dosya an rastkirin, bi navê te û di bin CC BY 4.0 de weşandî li cihê ku karê te bi xwe be.

Global Risks AlliancePublic Finance and Sovereign DebtFinance and Insurance ReadinessCountry Systems Risk and Resilience
Darayiya giştî û deynê serwerî

Bring an exposure or capital question to the Alliance.

Agahî û pirs îro vekirî ne. Pirsek referansekê distîne û gava piştî wê dide nasîn; serlêdan, drav, veqetandina hesabkirinê û tomarkirin tenê dema ku tîm, mercên wê û kapasîteya vekolînê hebin vedibin.