Skip to content

GRA · Financial Stability

Spatial financeWhere capital meets hazard, exposure and transition

Analysis and uncertainty

Contagion and amplification are studied with network, fire-sale and agent-based models, each of which captures one mechanism and misses others. This page sets out what each model captures, what it leaves out and why reconstructed networks need a warning label when bilateral data is not public.

01Register

Analysis and uncertainty on the record.

Ukuzinza Kwezezimali
  1. 01FieldsFinancial stability, Risk management and systemic risk, Capital markets and investment
  2. 02STEM methods5 canonical methods applied
  3. 03Topics8 subject pages
  4. 04Counterparts6 platforms in shared fields
  5. 05PublisherThe Global Risks Alliance
03Contagion models and their

Contagion models and their honesty limits.

ImodeliCapturesMisses
Eisenberg-Noe clearingDefault cascades through bilateral obligationsLiquidity, fire sales, behaviour
DebtRank-type centralitySystemic importance from network positionLoss magnitudes in stress
Common-asset fire-sale modelsLosses through overlapping portfoliosStrategic behaviour of sellers
Agent-based market modelsHeterogeneous behaviour and feedbackCalibration is weak
04Inqubo

How the process runs.

Process explorer · Process

Analysis and uncertainty: Catastrophe model pipeline

10 steps5 stages

Inqubo

Analysis and uncertainty: Catastrophe model pipeline

Catastrophe models usually have hazard, vulnerability, exposure and financial modules, and produce loss tables, average annual loss, exceedance curves, PML and TVaR.

  1. 01 Hazard

    1. 01Event catalogueDataset · Model developerThe hazard module holds a large catalogue of simulated events that represents a wide range of plausible scenarios.
    2. 03Hazard moduleModel · Model developerFor each event the hazard module gives the local hazard intensity that the vulnerability module reads.
  2. 02 Exposure and damage

    1. 02ExposureDataset · Ministry of financeThe exposure module houses the portfolio data, such as location-specific information.
    2. 04Vulnerability moduleModel · Model developerThe vulnerability module quantifies the expected damage to the exposures from an event.
  3. 03 Financial

    1. 05Financial moduleModel · Ministry of financeThe financial module calculates losses from all event scenarios. Ground-up, gross and net losses differ as shown below.
    2. 06Event loss tableDataset · Ministry of financeAn event loss table lists each event with its annual occurrence probability and its loss for the portfolio.
    3. 07Year loss tableDataset · Ministry of financeSome models also sample simulated years from event losses. This outline does not describe their format.
  4. 04 Metrics

    1. 08Exceedance probability curvesModel · Ministry of financeThe occurrence curve gives the chance that the largest loss in a year exceeds an amount. The aggregate curve does so for the sum of losses.
    2. 09AAL, PML and TVaRModel · Ministry of financeAverage annual loss sums event probability times loss. PML is one point on the occurrence curve.
  5. 05 Use of results

    1. 10Use of resultsDecision · Ministry of financeThe tail metrics are used when considering a portfolio's exposure and the level of catastrophe reinsurance an insurer requires.

Outline of an external standard or method, from its public sources. It describes what the framework says, not a record of any run. It does not show that Nexus or any partner performs, certifies or approves a step. A gate is a step of the method, never a Nexus approval.

05Validation

Reconstructed networks need a warning label.

Where bilateral data is unavailable, networks are reconstructed from aggregates by maximum entropy or similar methods, which tend to understate concentration. Results are labelled MODELLED and tested for sensitivity to the reconstruction method. Methods at GCRI network science.

06Ukungaqiniseki

How uncertainty is reported.

  1. 01

    State assumptions

    Each analysis lists its assumptions and the data it depends on.

  2. 02

    Quantify where possible

    Ranges and confidence are reported alongside central estimates.

  3. 03

    Validate and compare

    Models are checked against observations and, where possible, against other models.

  4. 04

    Publish limits

    What an analysis cannot show is stated beside what it can.

07Imithombo

Where this page's references lead.

The bodies and documents this page is read against. Status and editions change; each link goes to the issuing body.

08Imibuzo

Questions and answers.

Are the methods open?
Method descriptions are public on the STEM Commons. Code and data follow their own licences and access terms, listed in the source register.
ImibikoNikela

Nikela ngobufakazi kusuka kuleli khasi.

I-Reports iyincwadi yekota ye-Consortium. Lokho oakwaziyo ngalesi sihloko kungaba ubufakazi, icala noma ukulungisa kuhlelo olulandelayo, kubongwe wena futhi kushicilelwe ngaphansi kwe-CC BY 4.0 lapho kungumsebenzi wakho.

Global Risks AllianceFinancial StabilityScenario and Stress-TestGlobal Systems Risk and Resilience
Ukuzinza Kwezezimali

Bring an exposure or capital question to the Alliance.

Information and enquiries are open today. An enquiry receives a reference and names the next step; applications, payments, compute allocations and registrations open only when their team, terms and review capacity exist.