Skip to content

GRA · AI and Financial Model Risk

Spatial financeWhere capital meets hazard, exposure and transition

Stress and scenario models

Stress and scenario models project how losses, capital and liquidity would change under adverse conditions. They are used for supervisory stress tests, internal capital assessment and climate scenarios. Because they model rare events with little data, they carry more uncertainty than everyday models. This page sets out how stress models fail, how they are validated, and who decides how their results are used.

01Register

Stress and scenario models on the record.

02The question

Stress and scenario models: how the risk develops.

Verification and uncertainty. The dossier below sets out how the risk develops, what is measured, where the data come from, how it is modelled and who decides.

Mechanism

Few data points for extremes

Severe recessions and market crashes are rare, so the relationships linking scenarios to losses are estimated from few observations and may not hold in the next crisis.

Mechanism

Chains of models compound error

Scenario variables pass through satellite models for each portfolio, then aggregation. Errors at each link compound, and the end result looks more precise than it is.

Mechanism

Results drive capital

Where stress results set capital buffers, there are incentives to choose favourable assumptions. Supervisory models and challenge counter this.

Mechanism

Behaviour is often fixed

Many stress models hold balance sheets and management actions static, missing the reactions that amplify or dampen losses.

03Scenario model

Transition and physical risk on a portfolio.

Three scenario families after the NGFS framework move a sector portfolio through carbon costs and warming damages; the transmission view follows the losses to lenders, investors, public finances and households. Scenario: named assumptions about the future, not a forecast.

Controls

Carbon price at the horizon, orderly path
200 per tCO2
Delay before a disorderly transition
50% of horizon
Cost passed to customers
50%
Warming today above pre-industrial
1.30°C
Warming per decade, current policies
0.25°C
Damage coefficient
0.24% per °C²
Years ahead
25 years

Readouts

Worst scenario at the horizon
−33.6% of value
Numbers, methods and sources
YearOrderly transition (% value)Delayed, disorderly transition (% value)Current policies (% value)
0−0.38−0.38−0.38
3−2.87−0.53−0.67
6−5.36−0.68−0.97
9−7.84−0.84−1.27
12−10.33−0.99−1.57
15−12.82−7.12−1.87
18−15.31−15.05−2.17
21−17.80−23.00−2.48
24−20.29−30.94−2.79

Metodes

  1. Climate scenario families NGFS (2023), Climate Scenarios for central banks and supervisors, Phase IV
  2. Climate stress test of the financial system Battiston and others (2017), Nature Climate Change 7
  3. Damage function Nordhaus (2017), Revisiting the social cost of carbon, PNAS 114
  4. Transmission channels BCBS (2021), Climate-related risk drivers and their transmission channels
  5. Uncertainty fan (parameter Monte Carlo) Spiegelhalter, Pearson and Short (2011), Visualising uncertainty about the future, Science 333
  6. One-at-a-time sensitivity (tornado) Saltelli and others (2008), Global Sensitivity Analysis: The Primer, Wiley

Data

The model runs on the teaching values set by the controls. To calibrate it for a place, read it against these admitted layers and series, which this page’s map can draw:

  • Urban extents Natural Earth
  • Seaports Natural Earth
  • Past year, daily temperature (ERA5 via Open-Meteo) Open-Meteo.com (CC BY 4.0), Copernicus ERA5 (C3S/ECMWF) · register open-meteo.public-pages
  • Surface air temperature, daytime (AIRS) NASA AIRS · register nasa.gibs.context-live-layers
Transition and physical risk on a portfolio. Illustrative teaching model: it runs on the values set by the controls, not on measured data. Methods: Climate scenario families (NGFS (2023), Climate Scenarios for central banks and supervisors, Phase IV); Climate stress test of the financial system (Battiston and others (2017), Nature Climate Change 7); Damage function (Nordhaus (2017), Revisiting the social cost of carbon, PNAS 114).
04Aanwysers

What is measured, and how well.

Each indicator carries its unit, its cadence, the kind of source behind it and the evidence label a value would carry. No values are shown: a programme supplies them under its own authority.

IndicatorUnitCadenceSource typeLabel
Stress loss projection against realised loss in past downturnsratioper back-testBack-testingESTIMATED
Sensitivity of results to key assumptionschange in capital ratioper exerciseSensitivity analysisMODELLED
Management overlays on stress resultscurrencyper exerciseStress documentationDECLARED
Supervisory model versus firm model differencesdifference in projected lossesper exerciseSupervisory resultsPublished statistics
Stress models validated within cycleshareannualValidation recordsDECLARED
Scenario variables used per modelcountper exerciseModel documentationDECLARED
05Exposure, loss and capital

What stress and scenario models means for exposure, loss and capital.

The exposure, loss, scenario and capital views a risk officer, supervisor or ministry of finance would ask for, with the frameworks they report against. Structures follow supervisory and actuarial practice. Values are illustrative: never prices, ratings or advice.

Scenario pathways

How stress and scenario models could be stressed under the scenario families central banks and supervisors use.

OrderlyDisorderlyHot house world202520302035204020452050highlow
Scenario familyTransition riskPhysical riskWhat a stress test asks
OrderlyEarly, gradual policyLaerCan the book absorb a steady repricing?
DisorderlyLate, abrupt policyLower to mediumWhat breaks under a sudden repricing and credit migration?
Hot house worldLimited policyHigh and risingWhere do physical losses concentrate in collateral and insurance?
Scenario families as defined by the NGFS; the curves are an illustrative combined pressure index, not NGFS variables or forecasts.
NGFS climate scenarios · Network for Greening the Financial SystemIFRS S2 Climate-related Disclosures · ISSBTCFD recommendations · Financial Stability Board TCFDPrinciples for the effective management of climate-related financial risks · Basel Committee on Banking Supervision
06Bronne

Where the evidence comes from.

Named public datasets and institutional records, each with its licence class. Sources by agreement are used only under their terms and never republished.

BronWhat it givesLicence class
Federal Reserve stress test methodology documentationSupervisory model descriptionsOpenbare domein
EBA EU-wide stress test methodologyConstrained bottom-up approach and rulesFree, EU reuse terms
Bank of England stress testing documentationMethods and model approachFree, Bank of England terms
BCBS stress testing principlesInternational principles for stress testingFree, BIS terms
NGFS scenarios technical documentationClimate scenario models and limitsFree, NGFS terms
07Decisions

Who decides, and what the evidence serves.

AI and Financial Model Risk prepares evidence. The decisions below are taken by the authorities named, under their own rules, and never by the platform.

Wie besluitThe questionEvidence this page serves
Boards and risk committeesWhether stress results support capital and risk appetiteResults, sensitivities and validation
Model validatorsWhether stress models are fit for purposeBack-testing and benchmark evidence
SupervisorsHow firm and supervisory models are compared and usedExercise results and model reviews
Capital planning teamsWhich overlays are justifiedOverlay rationale and evidence

Outputs this topic produces

  • Guide to stress model chains and where error enters
  • Method note on back-testing stress models against past downturns
  • Brief on overlays and their governance
  • Questions for boards using stress results
08Core questions

What experts ask.

The questions concern how far to trust a model of the unprecedented.

  • Are the scenarios severe enough, and do they capture the risks that matter?
  • How are macroeconomic or physical scenarios translated into losses, and through which sub-models?
  • How much uncertainty accumulates along that chain?
  • Are second-round effects, such as fire sales and feedback to the economy, included?
  • How are results verified when the scenario has never occurred?
09Mechanisms

Mechanisms and drivers.

Stress tests link a scenario to outcomes through a series of models, for example from economic variables to default rates to losses to capital. Each link adds assumptions and uncertainty, and models calibrated on normal periods may not capture behaviour in extreme conditions. Climate scenarios extend horizons far beyond historical data, compounding uncertainty further.

Many stress tests consider institutions in isolation, missing interactions in which many firms’ responses amplify stress. Machine learning components add new verification challenges. Presenting results as precise numbers can create false confidence; ranges and sensitivity analysis communicate limits more honestly.

10Methods and data

How it is studied, and where the methods stop.

Method or dataWhat it showsLimits
Scenario designPlausible severe conditionsChoice of scenario shapes the answer
Satellite and loss modelsTranslation of scenarios into lossesCalibrated on limited stress data
Sensitivity and uncertainty analysisRange of plausible outcomesCannot capture unknown unknowns
Reverse stress testingConditions that would cause failureIdentifies vulnerabilities, not probabilities
System-wide modelsInteractions between institutionsRequire behavioural assumptions
12Vrae

Questions and answers.

Why are stress models riskier than everyday models?
Because they estimate behaviour in rare, severe conditions with little data, through chains of linked models, so uncertainty is large and harder to test.
What is a satellite model?
A model that translates macroeconomic scenario variables into a specific risk measure, such as credit losses for a portfolio.
How are stress models validated?
Through back-testing against past downturns where possible, benchmarking, sensitivity analysis and independent challenge of assumptions.
Is a stress test a forecast?
No. It estimates outcomes under a hypothetical scenario chosen to be severe but plausible. It does not predict that the scenario will occur.
Why report ranges rather than single numbers?
Because uncertainty accumulates through the chain of models. Ranges and sensitivities show how much results depend on assumptions.
Does the platform run stress tests for firms?
No. GRA does not perform firms’ risk management or validate their models. It publishes sector-level research and scenarios as they are reviewed.
VerslaeDra by

Dra bewyse vanaf hierdie bladsy by.

Reports is the Consortium’s quarterly publication. What you know about this subject can become evidence, a case or a correction in the next edition, credited to you and published under CC BY 4.0 where it is your own work.

Global Risks AllianceAI and Financial Model RiskMethods and TechnicalExponential Technology
KI- en finansiële modelrisiko

Bring an exposure or capital question to the Alliance.

Information and enquiries are open today. An enquiry receives a reference and names the next step; applications, payments, compute allocations and registrations open only when their team, terms and review capacity exist.