Skip to content

GRA · Actuarial and Quantitative Risk

Spatial financeWhere capital meets hazard, exposure and transition

Dependence and correlation

Diversification lowers capital only if risks do not move together. Dependence between lines, perils, regions and assets, especially in the tail, decides how much diversification credit is justified. Linear correlation often fails to capture tail dependence. This page sets out how dependence is modelled, where models understate joint losses, the data used and who decides.

01Bhalisa

Dependence and correlation on the record.

02The question

Dependence and correlation: how the risk develops.

Copulas, contagion and why correlations break in stress. The dossier below sets out how the risk develops, what is measured, where the data come from, how it is modelled and who decides.

Indlela yokusebenza

Correlation is not the whole story

Linear correlation measures average co-movement. Risks can look uncorrelated in normal times and move together in extremes.

Indlela yokusebenza

Copulas separate margins and dependence

Copulas model dependence separately from each risk’s distribution. The choice of copula changes tail dependence and capital.

Indlela yokusebenza

Common drivers create joint losses

A pandemic, a financial crisis or a large catastrophe can hit several lines and assets at once. Scenario-based dependence captures such drivers.

Indlela yokusebenza

Data on joint extremes are scarce

Few observations exist of several risks at their extremes together, so tail dependence parameters rest heavily on judgement.

03Spatial finance

Exposure, hazard and the exceedance curve.

Which places drive loss in a severe year, and how far it reaches into reinsurance. Illustrative design values.

Coastal exposure under cyclone and earthquake zones, beside the loss curve it produces.Illustrative design values, not a model output or a price.
04Izalathisi

What is measured, and how well.

Each indicator carries its unit, its cadence, the kind of source behind it and the evidence label a value would carry. No values are shown: a programme supplies them under its own authority.

IndicatorUnitCadenceSource typeIleyibhile
Correlation matrix entries used in capitalcorrelation coefficientsper modelCapital model documentationDECLARED
Tail dependence coefficientdimensionlessper analysisCopula fitsKUMODELWE
Diversification benefitpercent reduction in capitalper model runCapital modelsKUMODELWE
Joint extreme events in datacountper analysisHistorical dataKUQWALASELWE
Sensitivity of capital to dependence assumptionspercent changeper analysisSensitivity testingKUMODELWE
Copula family usedcategoricalper modelModel documentationDECLARED
05Beka iliso

Reserving workbench.

The screen a team would use to follow this subject: its measures, states and decisions. Names are examples and values are illustrative.

Reserving workbench: the screen’s structure, terms and states for Dependence and correlation.Example names and illustrative values; a design, not a record or a live system.
06Imithombo

Where the evidence comes from.

Named public datasets and institutional records, each with its licence class. Sources by agreement are used only under their terms and never republished.

UmthomboWhat it givesLicence class
Solvency II standard formula correlation parametersRegulatory correlation matricesFree, EU reuse terms
IAIS ICS technical specificationsCorrelation and aggregation in the ICSFree, IAIS terms
McNeil, Frey and Embrechts, Quantitative Risk ManagementReference text on dependence modellingProprietary, published book
R copula packageOpen-source copula fitting toolsOpen source, GPL
Supervisory reviews of internal model dependency calibrationFindings on dependence assumptionsFree, terms per supervisor
07Isilinganisi sokuphindwa nothotho lweziphumo

Trace a shock in dependence and correlation to the balance sheet.

Assembled from the Nexus Standards area profile Insurance and reinsurance: the shocks it names, the systems and sectors that carry the loss, the controls that dampen it and the data that observe it. Pick an initiating shock and step through the cascade to see which exposures it reaches and where losses could concentrate. The Map view places the run on an example geography with open data. Every weight is a stated assumption. An exercise, not a forecast, a valuation, a rating or investment advice. To model a place of your own choosing, open the full System Builder.

Iingozi

  • Tropical cyclone
  • Inyikima
  • Ice-jam flood
  • Umlilo wasendle
  • Storm surge (set off downstream)
  • Intense rainfall (set off downstream)
  • River flood (set off downstream)
  • Flash flood (set off downstream)
  • Dangerous surf (set off downstream)
  • Ukuqhawuka kombane okuxhaphakileyo (kubangela iziphumo ezilandelayo)
  • Ukufuduswa kwabantu abaninzi (kubangela iziphumo ezilandelayo)
  • Coastal flood (set off downstream)
  • Aftershock sequence (set off downstream)
  • Fault surface rupture (set off downstream)
  • Soil liquefaction (set off downstream)
  • Slope slide (set off downstream)
  • Rockfall (set off downstream)
  • Tsunami (set off downstream)

Izilawuli

  • NS-0 Umgaqo-siseko nemigaqo
  • NS-3 Ii-UNI zerekhodi yomngcipheko (igrama, uthelekiso lwakudala, igunya lokwabiwa)
  • NS-9 Ii-UNI zemeko (ukusasazwa, iimeko, iimeko zenkqubo)
  • NS-10 Imigaqo-nkqubo namagatya (izibophelelo ezifundeka ngoomatshini: inkcazo, ukubopha, uvavanyo nokunyanzeliswa)
  • NS-11 Ukuqinisekiswa nokubekwa kweliso (ubungqina, iziqinisekiso, uqwalaselo lokuhambelana ngaphandle kokuthemba)
  • NS-14 Ukuhambelana nokuthelekiswa nemigangatho yangaphandle
  • NRS-F3 Insurance, catastrophe risk and protection gaps
  • NRS-H113 Hazard family: Financial-system fragility (NHS-1 soc.financial-system)
  • NRS-U17 Universe platform profile: Insurance Nexus
  • NRS-H71 Hazard family: Deep-time and cosmic catastrophes (NHS-1 planet.deep-time)
  • NRS-H65 Hazard family: Planetary boundary transgressions (NHS-1 planet.boundary)
  • NRS-F8 Parametric and index-based risk transfer

Uqwalaselo

  • OECD Data Explorer (incl. Creditor Reporting System, insurance and pension statistics) (listed for reference)
  • Insurance statistics (listed for reference)
  • USGS earthquake GeoJSON summary feeds (listed for reference)
  • Direct economic loss attributed to disasters in relation to global gross domestic product (GDP)
  • Direct economic loss attributed to disasters in relation to global gross domestic product
  • (a) Number of commercial bank branches per 100,000 adults and (b) number of automated teller machines (ATMs) per 100,000 adults

Umzekelo wejografi

  • Western Europe: 152 hexagonal cells
  • Isantya semvula, isiqingatha seyure esidlulileyo (IMERG), NASA GIBS
  • Izibane zasebusuku namhlanje, ukuqhawuka kombane (VIIRS Day/Night Band), NASA GIBS
  • Amanzi aphezu komhlaba phantsi kwamafu, 30 m (OPERA DSWx-S1 radar), NASA GIBS
  • Carbon monoxide, smoke transport (AIRS), NASA GIBS
08Decisions

Who decides, and what the evidence serves.

Actuarial and Quantitative Risk prepares evidence. The decisions below are taken by the authorities named, under their own rules, and never by the platform.

Who decidesThe questionEvidence this page serves
Capital model ownersWhich dependence structure to useData, expert judgement and sensitivity
Chief risk officersHow much diversification credit to acceptDiversification benefit and stress results
SupervisorsWhether dependence calibrations are prudentModel reviews and peer comparison
ValidatorsWhether dependence assumptions are supportedBack-testing and scenario evidence

Outputs this topic produces

  • Guide to correlation, copulas and tail dependence
  • Method note on calibrating dependence with sparse joint data
  • Brief on diversification benefit and its sensitivity
  • Questions for boards on diversification credit
09Exposure, loss and capital

What dependence and correlation means for exposure, loss and capital.

The exposure, loss, scenario and capital views a risk officer, supervisor or ministry of finance would ask for, with the frameworks they report against. Structures follow supervisory and actuarial practice. Values are illustrative: never prices, ratings or advice.

Exposure and loss at return periods

How losses from dependence and correlation grow with severity, gross and net of reinsurance, against capital.

1 in 101 in 501 in 1001 in 250grossnet of reinsurance800
Return periodAnnual probabilityGross lossNet lossNet, capital = 100
1 in 100.10141010
1 in 500.02332121
1 in 1000.01462727
1 in 2500.004683939
Ilahleko yonyaka ephakathi3.12.22.2
Illustrative loss index for a example portfolio (capital = 100): the exceedance-probability form insurers and supervisors read. Not data on any institution, not a price or a rating.
NGFS climate scenarios · Network for Greening the Financial SystemIFRS S2 Climate-related Disclosures · ISSBTCFD recommendations · Financial Stability Board TCFDPrinciples for the effective management of climate-related financial risks · Basel Committee on Banking Supervision
10Core questions

The questions experts ask.

  • How strongly do risks move together, especially in the tail?
  • Is linear correlation an adequate summary of dependence?
  • Which mechanisms cause dependence to rise in a crisis?
  • How should dependence be represented in capital models?
  • How do common exposures and model homogeneity create hidden dependence?
11Mechanisms

Why correlations break.

Linear correlation measures average co-movement and is adequate for jointly normal variables, but financial and insurance risks are rarely normal. Two portfolios can have the same correlation yet very different behaviour in extremes. Tail dependence measures the tendency of variables to be extreme together, and it is what matters for capital and solvency.

Copulas separate the dependence structure from the marginal distributions, allowing modellers to choose dependence with or without tail dependence. Choice of copula matters: Gaussian copulas have no tail dependence, while t and Archimedean copulas can capture it. Misuse of Gaussian copulas in structured credit was widely discussed after the global financial crisis.

Mechanisms behind rising dependence include common shocks, such as a recession or a single large catastrophe affecting many lines; feedback, such as fire sales that push prices down for all holders; and contagion through counterparty and funding links. Common models and data across firms can also create correlated decisions.

Dependence also arises between assets and liabilities. A catastrophe can raise insurance claims while depressing the value of investments held to pay them, and a financial crisis can weaken reinsurers when cedants most need them; such wrong-way risk is easy to miss when risks are modelled separately.

12Methods and data

Methods and their limits.

Copulas

Copula modelling

Modelling joint distributions with chosen dependence structures; tail parameters are hard to estimate.

Uxinzelelo

Stressed correlations

Using correlations observed in stress periods; stress periods are few.

Structural

Causal and network models

Modelling the mechanisms that link risks; demanding in data.

Limits: dependence in the tail is estimated from very few joint extremes, and dependence structures can change with market conditions and policy.

14Imibuzo

Imibuzo neempendulo.

Why is correlation not enough for capital?
Because it measures average co-movement and can miss the tendency of risks to move together in extremes, which drives capital.
What is a copula?
A function that joins individual risk distributions into a joint distribution, specifying how they depend on each other.
What is tail dependence?
The tendency of two risks to produce extreme outcomes at the same time, measured by tail dependence coefficients.
Is correlation the same as dependence?
No. Correlation is one summary of linear dependence; dependence in the tail can differ greatly.
Why do diversification benefits shrink in crises?
Because common shocks, feedback and contagion make risks move together when markets are stressed.
Does GRA assess firms’ diversification?
No. It studies methods only.
IingxeloNikela

Faka ubungqina obuvela kweli phepha.

Reports is the Consortium’s quarterly publication. What you know about this subject can become evidence, a case or a correction in the next edition, credited to you and published under CC BY 4.0 where it is your own work.

Global Risks AllianceActuarial and Quantitative RiskMethods and TechnicalFinance and Insurance Readiness
Actuarial and Quantitative Risk

Bring an exposure or capital question to the Alliance.

Information and enquiries are open today. An enquiry receives a reference and names the next step; applications, payments, compute allocations and registrations open only when their team, terms and review capacity exist.